I was just listening to a quiz question on the radio, pertaining to the movie “Psycho”, and thoughts turned to my steaming compost pile. And it generated a half-baked thought.
No, I didn’t hear voices when the idea came to me to ask the tree trimming guys if I could have the wood chips from my trees. But it was one of those wildly auspicious thoughts that seemed to be inspired by God, and I thought I might as well ask. What’s the best or the worst that could happen?
I realize that everyone’s concept and everyone’s experience of God are different, and that our stories could be questioned or refuted even or especially by other people of faith. So, on the one hand, those things might be better kept to ourselves. On the other hand, discernment requires a community of people of faith — even if it’s a trusted friend or two who can challenge what we think we know, or affirm it.
My point is, there are a lot of people in this world who have mental issues (probably most), and some who may hear voices, and may think they’re hearing God telling them to do things. There is also a lot of bad and damaging theology out there that propagates an unhealthy concept of a wrathful God who delights in retribution. If those people who sell that unhealthy concept would do God a favor, instead of themselves with their crowd-pleasing rhetoric(*), there would be all sorts of benefits to society and the rest of Creation (including animals, of course). In other words, they should stop selling “hate speech” wrapped in a poor Christian veneer.
(* I’m reminded of the charismatic preacher who had a megachurch in Oklahoma City(?) and lots of money, who lost it all when he started preaching good news, instead of hell-based theology. He acted on faith — maybe the most authentic transformation of his career — and paid a huge price. His megahoard didn’t want to hear any good news about God. They wanted the sideshow. The story had a happy ending, most memorably, two events by people who heard his story: being invited to speak at a GLBT church in San Francisco, where the lesbian pastor washed his feet, and then was also invited by an Episcopal church in his city, to use their facilities for worship services for the couple hundred of congregants that didn’t leave when his megachurch bit the dust.)
I could go in so many directions with this. But I want to go back to people who hear voices, or believe that God is giving them ideas to do things, and the need to differentiate or discern what’s of God and what isn’t. Joan of Arc was an example. And interestingly, The Episcopal Church added her day to Lesser Feasts and Fasts a few years ago. They didn’t necessarily buy into whether or not she actually heard God’s voice. But they did feel that she was a good example of someone who acted on faith with courage. And honestly, right or wrong, her story was pretty amazing. (I may try to find an article I found about that sometime.) One of my favorite TV shows from a few years ago was “Joan of Arcadia”.
But for people with the type of mental illness that causes them to hear voices, and think God’s telling them to do this or that — usually harmful things — a theological shift among preachers and religious teachers who “sell hell” for fame and profit could actually save lives. In other words, if an inner voice that compels a mentally ill person to do something horrible wasn’t believed to be God, maybe even the person hearing the voice would be able to differentiate, and not act on whatever they hear — thus acting on faith instead of delusion by not acting out.
How does one discern between acting on faith or acting on delusion?
I’m reminded again of this quote, which at this moment pertains to both people who speak, and people who hear….
“When the voice of God is invoked
on behalf of those
who have no voice,
it is time to listen.
But when the name of God is used
to benefit the interests
of those who are speaking,
it is time to be very careful.”
– Jim Wallis, Who Speaks for God?
[If things go well within my lifetime, I will "come out" at my funeral with an experience I had during a Saturday morning Eucharist on 10/23/98. If my life turns out to be a futile waste of time and energy, I won't. Hint: It was a "St. Francis event" that happened sometime between the Thanksgiving prayer and Dismissal, which at that time had nothing to do with animals. If it was of God and not delusion, I have reason to believe that things will go well. And a lot of good things have happened in recent years, even though I'm never satisfied with the way things are.]